Jan. 21, 2025

Wrestling with Forgiveness: UnitedHealth CEO and Luigi Mangione

Question? Comment? Message me!

Support the show

Hi, Jimmy here! If you found value, please support me at patreon.com/guiltfreefaith.

Chapters

00:00 - The Concept of Forgiveness in Christianity

10:07 - Christian Perspective on Health Insurance Issues

Transcript

WEBVTT

00:00:00.080 --> 00:00:10.570
One of the cornerstones of Christian faith is that Christ died for our sins past, present and future, for those that believe on him.

00:00:10.570 --> 00:00:34.874
So one of the keys to Christ's purpose was forgiveness, and when we talk about Christ as the Lamb of God, essentially Christ is sacrificed to cover all of these sins that we ourselves can't get rid of, can't charge off or blame on somebody else or pay off.

00:00:34.874 --> 00:00:53.829
If you believe in sin, if you believe that there are evil things that people do, whether it's by their own agency, whether they can even control it, which I'm not sure they can that's another whole video.

00:00:53.829 --> 00:01:00.725
But the idea is that we need forgiveness and thankfully we don't have to rely on other people for forgiveness.

00:01:00.725 --> 00:01:21.125
If our eternal fate rested on whether someone else would forgive us, wow, we really have a problem there, because oftentimes we're not forgiven or it's not done fully, or we're on the other side of the equation.

00:01:21.125 --> 00:01:24.471
Are there people you've not forgiven?

00:01:24.471 --> 00:01:26.132
Put it in the comments.

00:01:26.132 --> 00:01:27.540
Who haven't you forgiven?

00:01:27.540 --> 00:01:29.626
Why haven't you forgiven them?

00:01:30.367 --> 00:01:32.272
I want to welcome you to Guilt-Free Faith.

00:01:32.272 --> 00:01:34.864
My name is Jimmy James Johnson.

00:01:34.864 --> 00:01:37.670
Guilt does not live here.

00:01:37.670 --> 00:01:39.474
You're at the wrong place.

00:01:40.260 --> 00:01:45.891
Most of us would agree that shoplifting isn't as bad as murder.

00:01:45.891 --> 00:01:51.719
Right, a parking violation isn't as bad as an armed robbery.

00:01:51.719 --> 00:02:00.287
We have some kind of basic social contract and understanding that some things are just more harmful than others.

00:02:00.287 --> 00:02:05.947
So we want to deter them, we want to punish more severely for them.

00:02:05.947 --> 00:02:23.209
And the problem with that, as a Christian, is that all sins are—this is what the Bible says, this is not what Jimmy's saying—all sins are equal in the eyes of the Lord.

00:02:23.209 --> 00:02:26.655
That's a real mind-blower.

00:02:26.655 --> 00:02:28.346
How could that even be?

00:02:28.346 --> 00:02:54.782
How could God look upon something as minor as littering or loitering and compare that to essay or some type of vicious attack or indeed a horrible white-collar crime, which those are often given a pass, which is why we're talking about it?

00:02:54.782 --> 00:03:01.544
So as Christians, we're faced with this thing of looking at okay, here's this healthcare insurance company CEO.

00:03:01.544 --> 00:03:04.457
If he is in fact, this is just all alleged.

00:03:04.457 --> 00:03:06.983
Okay, I don't know.

00:03:06.983 --> 00:03:12.461
I haven't seen the records, I've not deposed this guy, I haven't followed his career.

00:03:12.461 --> 00:03:13.704
I have no idea.

00:03:13.704 --> 00:03:18.876
I'm just going by what's alleged his career.

00:03:18.876 --> 00:03:19.217
I have no idea.

00:03:19.217 --> 00:03:21.580
I'm just going by what's alleged and what I've personally seen and experienced.

00:03:21.602 --> 00:03:29.740
Now in the world's eyes, one of the surprising things about this is the quote victim of this case.

00:03:29.740 --> 00:03:38.911
The victim isn't really garnering a lot of support or sympathy.

00:03:38.911 --> 00:03:45.967
Ever since this happened, there's been an outcry amongst virtually everybody.

00:03:45.967 --> 00:04:09.370
I know certainly all the social media forums, many YouTube videos, even mainstream news outlets have been reporting like wow, there's really a groundswell of tolerance, understanding, compassion for the so-called offender or shooter in this case.

00:04:09.370 --> 00:04:21.418
I saw something on the news the other day talking about where this Luigi gentleman is imprisoned and even the prisoners are supporting him.

00:04:21.418 --> 00:04:26.408
Even the prisoners are like hey, free Luigi, it's not right that he's in here.

00:04:26.408 --> 00:04:46.367
So even those people in the most marginalized edges of society are coming to the aid, in a sense, of the rights and the circumstances around how this gentleman is being charged.

00:04:46.367 --> 00:04:54.668
And, as I recall, he is being charged now with first-degree murder in addition to other charges.

00:04:54.668 --> 00:04:58.382
So that's as serious as you can get.

00:04:59.384 --> 00:05:11.723
Now, again, as a normal everyday person who has been screwed over by insurance companies, is it really a surprise?

00:05:11.723 --> 00:05:41.877
Tremendously saddened by the passing of this guy who ostensibly is chief of another one of these organizations that apparently, or allegedly, is responsible for a lot of denials of care, up to one in three, to put that in perspective, just think all these people that are going to the doctor.

00:05:41.877 --> 00:05:51.160
The doctor is recommending care, they're prescribing something, and the insurance company it's not like.

00:05:51.160 --> 00:05:55.627
They're occasionally like, oh no, that's experimental.

00:05:55.627 --> 00:06:02.036
Occasionally like, oh no, that's experimental, that's kind of off the books, that's pseudoscience.

00:06:02.036 --> 00:06:11.288
No, these are treatments and prescriptions prescribed by their own colleagues in the American Medical Association.

00:06:11.288 --> 00:06:12.550
Here are the doctors.

00:06:12.550 --> 00:06:23.305
They're part of the healthcare system and certainly there are plenty of physicians that consult for the insurance companies.

00:06:23.834 --> 00:06:34.281
Despite this linkage between medical doctors and the health insurance that's supposed to pay for them and the treatments they prescribe.

00:06:34.281 --> 00:06:41.862
We even have a lot of doctors saying, man, yeah, I can't always give my patients what they need.

00:06:41.862 --> 00:06:50.928
Yeah, I am not able to put the prescriptions in the hands of people that need it.

00:06:50.928 --> 00:06:54.584
I'm the one that's trained to practice medicine.

00:06:54.584 --> 00:06:58.725
I'm the one that decides what the proper treatment is.

00:06:58.725 --> 00:07:11.007
As long as the patient agrees with that, that person should be able to go and avail themselves of that treatment and their health insurance should cover whatever portion that is.

00:07:11.007 --> 00:07:13.459
Maybe there's also a co-pay, maybe there's.

00:07:13.459 --> 00:07:15.394
That's one of the problems.

00:07:15.394 --> 00:07:24.475
Right, there's a million loopholes and scenarios and it's nuts, right, which is what many people feel, including myself, like part of the plan.

00:07:24.475 --> 00:07:25.939
Right, you can't navigate it.

00:07:25.939 --> 00:07:37.170
Right, it's like you need a whole nother degree just to try to call all these people, sort through all these things, fax them, email them, all that stuff.

00:07:37.915 --> 00:07:55.209
For me, the only reason why I'm alive and I've gotten the treatment that I've received is not because I have a wonderful insurance company, it's not because I'm sitting at the top of the socioeconomic heap, no, it's not that.

00:07:55.209 --> 00:07:59.646
It's because I had loved ones, particularly my mom.

00:07:59.646 --> 00:08:16.072
Mom love you Particularly, mom mom, mom, mom, mom, love you, love you.

00:08:16.072 --> 00:08:25.108
Okay, my mom has spent countless hours and I'm not exaggerating Over the course of my lifetime.

00:08:25.108 --> 00:08:30.358
She's easily spent a thousand hours or more.

00:08:30.358 --> 00:08:33.688
That's probably even conservative.

00:08:34.230 --> 00:08:53.357
There's been times in my life where taking care of me in terms of being my advocate and representing me vis-a-vis these insurance companies that I'm paying to protect me and provide for me, without her advocacy, like I would just be a goner.

00:08:53.357 --> 00:09:00.547
See, like I would just be a goner.

00:09:00.547 --> 00:09:06.378
She's the one that really took the time to fight these fights and she's the one who has filled me in along the way on a lot of the details.

00:09:06.378 --> 00:09:28.498
And let me tell you, it is shady, it's slimy, it's shit Any adjective that you want to attach to the types of hoops, the types of underhanded garbage that my mom and I have run into trying to get the right medical care.

00:09:28.498 --> 00:09:29.700
It's just astonishing.

00:09:29.700 --> 00:09:37.456
Only if you've been through it would you fully appreciate how severe the situation is.

00:09:38.217 --> 00:09:44.333
Living by the world's rules, a lot of people feel like, hey, live by the sword, die by the sword.

00:09:44.333 --> 00:09:46.719
Right, you're an executive.

00:09:46.719 --> 00:09:49.750
You're making decisions that impact people's lives.

00:09:49.750 --> 00:09:53.447
You're causing suffering, perhaps even death.

00:09:53.447 --> 00:09:55.717
You're profiting from this.

00:09:55.717 --> 00:09:57.886
You're making millions and millions and millions.

00:09:57.886 --> 00:10:00.232
You're getting millions in bonuses.

00:10:00.232 --> 00:10:04.431
Right, you're literally being paid to kill people.

00:10:04.431 --> 00:10:06.336
That's how a lot of people look at this.

00:10:07.780 --> 00:10:09.886
I personally find it hard to disagree with that.

00:10:09.886 --> 00:10:12.436
Maybe I'm a little emotional.

00:10:12.436 --> 00:10:14.363
Maybe I'm traumatized from my past experiences.

00:10:14.363 --> 00:10:14.985
Maybe I'm a little emotional.

00:10:14.985 --> 00:10:17.407
Maybe I'm traumatized from my past experiences.

00:10:17.407 --> 00:10:18.749
All of that, I'm sure, is true.

00:10:18.749 --> 00:10:37.214
But just looking at it factually and reading about it, learning about other people's cases, talking to other advocates like my mom, I don't know what else to call this type of flagrant disregard for human life.

00:10:37.214 --> 00:10:45.913
I don't know what else to call it, and I have at least a decent vocabulary, but that's what it is.

00:10:45.913 --> 00:10:46.595
That's horrible.

00:10:46.595 --> 00:10:55.871
As somebody that's had health issues pretty much since when I was a kid, that's had health issues pretty much since when I was a kid.

00:10:55.871 --> 00:10:57.094
Okay, so I've been in this system.

00:10:57.094 --> 00:11:00.538
I know more about it than I would like to.

00:11:00.538 --> 00:11:02.541
Can you relate to me anyone?

00:11:02.541 --> 00:11:06.524
All right, tell me in the comments, so I feel like I'm not alone.

00:11:06.764 --> 00:11:20.418
So this guy he's mad, ostensibly because of insurance mistreatment, takes matters into his own hands and offs this executive.

00:11:20.418 --> 00:11:28.038
So, as a Christian, what's our reaction to the offing of this UnitedHealthcare CEO?

00:11:28.038 --> 00:11:31.548
We know how we may feel about it.

00:11:31.548 --> 00:11:37.177
We know what the facts may show about this person's tenure and their behavior.

00:11:37.177 --> 00:11:39.388
We know about their bank account.

00:11:39.388 --> 00:11:43.676
How are we supposed to feel about what's been done to them?

00:11:43.676 --> 00:11:50.317
Okay, and then also, how are we supposed to feel about the person that is accused of doing it?

00:11:51.085 --> 00:11:54.394
As a Christian, we're supposed to forgive everybody.

00:11:54.394 --> 00:12:16.756
Hey, have you been in a situation with a health insurance company that was so damaging, that was so emotional, that was so tragic, that you're having a hell of a time forgiving this guy for being part of that system?

00:12:16.756 --> 00:12:18.458
Are you pissed off?

00:12:18.458 --> 00:12:20.019
Are you in pain?

00:12:20.019 --> 00:12:22.606
Are you missing out on care you need?

00:12:22.606 --> 00:12:37.378
Hey, let people know in the comments, because not everybody knows If you've been blessed and you've been healthy and you haven't been put through the health insurance ringer, you may not know how serious of a problem this is.

00:12:37.378 --> 00:12:41.676
You may not realize that this is not exaggerated.

00:12:41.676 --> 00:12:45.897
It's not about trying to curb medical fraud.

00:12:45.897 --> 00:12:50.773
That, yeah, we deny all these people because they're trying to scam us.

00:12:50.773 --> 00:12:51.671
No, no, no.